Add To Cart is brought to you by
Were you forwarded this email? Sign up here to get the next edition.
I called Grant Arnott in the days after Power Retail and Click Frenzy went into receivership. Not to record anything. Just to check in and to tell him what he and the things he built meant to me and to a lot of careers across this industry. What he shared in that call made it clear very quickly that this was a conversation the Add To Cart audience needed to hear.
Grant built Power Retail and Click Frenzy with no outside capital, no VC, and no MBA. Profitable from the start. Making comfortably over a million dollars a year by 2019. And then he made one decision that he says will be his greatest regret. This episode is not a post-mortem on a business. It's an honest account of what it costs a person to build something for 15 years, make decisions under real pressure, and find their way through when it doesn't go the way you imagined.
Cheers
Bushy
EPISODE CHEAT SHEET
⏭️ SKIP TO THE GOOD BITS
The announcement and what actually led to receivership (4:05)
Running a business with less than nothing: the last 12 months (8:12)
The private equity decision Grant will regret for life (12:23)
The $100M valuation and the GrabOne acquisition (19:54)
The oh-shit moment: 2022, rising rates, and a closed IPO window (24:54)
The call that changed everything (28:07)
The darkest period, the psychologist, and what brought Grant back (34:20)
Life after business prison: what's next for Grant (47:19)
💬 QUOTE OF THE DAY
"If I made a business mistake it was maybe $200k at worst and we could ride through it. A private equity firm with bets on a whole lot of different things can make a $10 million fuck-up and shrug it off. And if you are that $10 million fuck-up..."
🧠 THE BIG LESSON
The three questions Grant wishes he'd asked before taking PE money
Grant's businesses were profitable, cashflow positive, and growing when private equity came knocking. He didn't need the money. He was, as he put it, swept along by the excitement of a $100M valuation and an IPO plan. Twelve years of organic growth unravelled in three. The questions he'd ask now are simple. Most founders never ask them before the deal.
Question 1: Do you actually need it?
PE interest is a signal you're doing something right, but it's also the moment you're most likely to get swept up in a number that may not reflect reality. Grant's business was turning over $10M. He couldn't connect the dots on how it was worth $100M, and he didn't press hard enough to find out. If the business is profitable and cash flow positive, the burden of proof is on the capital, not the founder.
“We didn't need it. It was always profitable. It was cashflow positive. And what would we put the money into? I was fairly relaxed about it. If nothing happened, nothing happened.”
Question 2: Do you live in the same universe as your investor?
PE firms are optimised for portfolio scale and returns, not for the founder's definition of success. Grant wanted financial security for his family. His investors wanted the largest possible exit. Those goals are not the same thing, and he didn't realise the gap until it was too late. Before you sign, ask: What does winning actually look like for them and is that the same as what winning looks like for you?
"For me, it was really clear that financial security for my family was not something of any interest to our partners at all. It was all about how big we could get."
Question 3: Is it real skin in the game, or chicken skin?
When things go wrong, a PE firm with dozens of bets can absorb a $10M loss and move on. For a founder, that same $10M is a matter of life or death. Four of Grant's board directors resigned in early 2023. No consequences for them. Complete devastation for Grant and his family. Before you partner, understand what the asymmetry looks like if it goes wrong for both of you.
"If they can smoke bomb overnight and there's no consequences, you just don't have real partners.”
PE money is not neutral capital. It changes the stakes, the decision-making, and the culture of your business from day one. For a self-funded founder who has built something profitable through organic growth, the question is never "why not?" It's always "why?"
✏️ ECOMMERCE ACTION TIPS
Before taking an investment, audit your actual needs. Not your appetite for growth, but your genuine funding gap. A profitable, cashflow-positive business that takes on unnecessary debt is not stronger; it's more fragile. (~13:48)
Understand your investor's definition of winning before you sign. Specifically, what they expect to get out of the deal, at what multiple, and over what timeline. The gap between your version of success and theirs is where most founder-investor partnerships break down. (~45:16)
Protect your cost base before you protect your growth rate. When cuts to marketing set off the downward spiral, the business couldn't compete or course-correct. Cash-positive growth beats fast-negative growth every time. (~10:57)
Know whether you're a builder or a buyer. Acquiring businesses you don't deeply understand adds complexity that your culture and team were never built to absorb. Grant described himself as a builder: "I know what's underneath it and inside it and that's exciting." Buying someone else's underneath is an entirely different skill set. (~48:01)
Ask for help before you reach the edge. The psychologist Grant saw described him as "really high risk." He went because he knew he was in serious trouble. The earlier you reach out, the more options you have. Lifeline: 13 11 14. Beyond Blue: 1300 22 4636. (~37:43)
🎧 OTHER EPS YOU MIGHT LIKE
Real Ecommerce Talk: Success, Failure and Not Giving a F*ck with Anaita Sarkar | EP441
Six months of not looking at the numbers was all it took for Anaita to nearly go into voluntary administration. A raw, honest account of how a founder rebuilds when the financials fall apart and what it actually takes to turn it around.
How Glow Capital Partners Choose Bankable Ecommerce Founders | EP354
The investor's side of the table. What PE actually looks for, how they think about founder fatigue, and why the founders most likely to attract capital are the ones who least need it. Worth understanding both sides of the conversation before you have it.
Proud Poppy's Growth Breaking Point: The Decisions That Saved the Business | EP587
Over-ordered stock, a warehouse lease signed at the worst possible time, and a revenue miss that snowballed fast. Tara McKeon on the decisions founders face when growth goes wrong and why transparency with your community can be the thing that pulls you through.
💬 CONTINUE THE CONVERSATION
This episode is going to sit with a lot of people for a long time. Was there a moment in Grant's story that hit close to home? Have you faced a decision like Grant’s and how did you think through it? And if you're going through something tough right now, this community is full of people who've been in the grind and come out the other side. Come and share where you're at.
Not a member yet? It's free to join. 600+ ecommerce operators talking shop every week.
